Plains of San Agustin Incident
Explore Visualizations
View this incident on the interactive incident map and timeline
Evidence quality · 6 components
Behavioral anomalousness · 4 components
TL;DR
The entire case rests on secondhand accounts of what Barney Barnett allegedly told friends - he died in 1969 without ever making a public statement - and his wife Ruth's 1947 daily diary, examined by Kevin Randle, contains no mention of any unusual event despite Barnett allegedly telling multiple people about the crash within months of it occurring.
Confirmed
- ✓Grady 'Barney' Barnett was a real US Soil Conservation Service civil engineer based in Socorro, NM; he died in 1969 without ever publicly documenting his account
- ✓Stanton Friedman first heard the Barnett account from Vern and Jean Maltais on October 24, 1978; the Maltaises initially provided no date - 'July 1947' is a researcher inference
- ✓Gerald Anderson - the only additional claimed eyewitness - admitted to forging a telephone bill and his FBI-analyzed family diary was determined to have text added after the fact
- ✓Herbert Dick's archaeological team at Bat Cave on the southeastern edge of the Plains during July 1947 had direct sightlines across the basin and saw nothing unusual
Unresolved
- ?What Barney Barnett actually experienced - multiple independent secondhand sources heard some version of his story, suggesting he told something to multiple people
- ?Whether the story Barnett told was localized to the Plains of San Agustin or was misattributed geographically by imprecise retelling
- ?Why Ruth Barnett's daily diary is silent if Barnett witnessed something significant enough to remember and recount to friends
Strongest mundane explanation
Barnett had a real but mundane classified experience somewhere in western New Mexico that was embellished through repeated retelling and subsequently conflated with the Roswell events - consistent with William Moore privately abandoning the Plains location theory by 1985, five years after publishing it, and with his associate Shandera's 1991 public statement that 'there is no person that found anything in San Agustin.'
The Plains of San Agustin incident claims that a disc-shaped craft carrying humanoid bodies crashed on a vast, remote basin in west-central New Mexico in July 1947 - approximately 150-180 miles west of the Foster Ranch debris field associated with the primary Roswell incident. The claim rests entirely on secondhand accounts of conversations with Grady 'Barney' Barnett, a U.S. Soil Conservation Service civil engineer who died in 1969 without ever giving a public interview or leaving a written account. His story entered UFO literature in 1980 through researchers William Moore and Charles Berlitz, who had obtained it from Barnett's friends the Maltaises. Ruth Barnett's 1947 diary - the only contemporaneous household document - contains no mention of any unusual event. The only additional eyewitness to emerge, Gerald Anderson in 1990, was subsequently shown to have derived his 'archaeologist corroboration' from a high school teacher he encountered ten years after the alleged event, forged a family diary, forged a telephone bill, and admitted to the latter forgery. Herbert Dick's archaeological team, the only documented field group on the Plains edge during the relevant period, saw nothing. By 1985 William Moore himself had privately abandoned the Plains story. Kevin Randle, who initially credited the account, concluded after systematic investigation: 'Nothing happened on the Plains in July 1947.' Stanton Friedman maintained until his death in 2019 that the Plains represented a second crash site from the same 1947 event - a minority position not sustained by independent evidence.
Key Facts
- ›The Plains of San Agustin is a large, remote, high-altitude enclosed basin (bolson) spanning Catron and Socorro Counties, NM - approximately 150-180 miles west of the Foster Ranch debris field, in a separate topographic basin and county
- ›Grady 'Barney' Barnett was a real U.S. Soil Conservation Service civil engineer based in Socorro, NM; he died in 1969 without ever publicly documenting his alleged experience
- ›The story entered UAP literature in 1980 via 'The Roswell Incident' (Moore/Berlitz), sourced entirely from Barnett's friends Vern and Jean Maltais - who initially had no specific date for the story
- ›Ruth Barnett kept a daily diary throughout 1947 - the only contemporaneous household document; Kevin Randle examined it and found no mention of any unusual event, military contact, or sworn secrecy
- ›Gerald Anderson (1990) is the only claimed additional eyewitness; investigation proved he identified his 'archaeologist' witness from a high school teacher he met ten years after the alleged event, forged a family diary, and forged a telephone bill - and admitted to the latter
- ›The only documented archaeological team on the edge of the Plains during July 1947, Herbert Dick's team at Bat Cave, had clear sightlines across the basin and saw nothing
- ›William Moore, who first published the account in 1980, had privately abandoned the Plains story by 1985; his associate Jaime Shandera stated publicly in May 1991 'there is no person that found anything in San Agustin'
- ›Stanton Friedman maintained the dual-crash-site hypothesis (Plains = craft body; Foster Ranch = debris scatter) until his death in 2019; this position is not held by other major Roswell researchers
- ›Kevin Randle, who initially credited the Plains account, published his systematic investigation in 'The Truth About the UFO Crash at Roswell' (1994) and concluded: 'Nothing happened on the Plains in July 1947'